~ knotless Search/
↑↓ move↵ open⇧↵ all results
0
0
391 lines · 24.1 KB Raw History
{
  "description": "Commit and record MACs (spec/SPACES.md, \"MACs\"). For each commit and record: `key_share` asks with `accept_signature`; `shared_secret` is its secret with the author's KEM key; `header` is the covered header's value, `base` the signature base, `mac` HMAC-SHA256 of `base` under `shared_secret`, and `response` the headers a repo host answers. `accept_signature`: each Accept-Signature header read for `profile`, and what it yields: `request` {label, key_share, signature_params} (the Inner List as serialized), or null where it asks for no MAC; `refused` true where it must be refused, decapsulating the key share included.",
  "commit": [
    {
      "comment": "a commit",
      "author_private_key": "10258b259047e3e1f44beae062b93f53f9a889b7c47d5b95a840b56965b4254e",
      "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
      "shared_secret": "afcf99a99e3e853a91662abc5201db0528e75737032b7dde252e9bf030735485",
      "commit": {
        "ver": 1,
        "repo": "did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz",
        "space": "at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general",
        "rev": "3mzudodppwc2e",
        "data": "54bdbf9b4d472e2ec7b2e8712614c2f84240731b52b74f4e53542363a18d2df0"
      },
      "accept_signature": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "header": "ver=1, repo=\"did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz\", space=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general\", rev=\"3mzudodppwc2e\", data=:VL2/m01HLi7HsuhxJhTC+EJAcxtSt09OU1QjY6GNLfA=:",
      "base": "\"atproto-space-commit\";sf: ver=1, repo=\"did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz\", space=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general\", rev=\"3mzudodppwc2e\", data=:VL2/m01HLi7HsuhxJhTC+EJAcxtSt09OU1QjY6GNLfA=:\n\"@signature-params\": (\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "mac": "a21430aabfe724751178006b612f6ca60c763514a07aaebddc71e95bc1135288",
      "response": {
        "atproto-space-commit": "ver=1, repo=\"did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz\", space=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general\", rev=\"3mzudodppwc2e\", data=:VL2/m01HLi7HsuhxJhTC+EJAcxtSt09OU1QjY6GNLfA=:",
        "signature-input": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
        "signature": "mac=:ohQwqr/nJHUReABrYS9spgx2NRSgeq693HHpW8ETUog=:"
      }
    },
    {
      "comment": "the empty repo, asked with alg and another label",
      "author_private_key": "10258b259047e3e1f44beae062b93f53f9a889b7c47d5b95a840b56965b4254e",
      "key_share": "did:key:zDnaeeRUs5P6aU9nQbNijvpHqdxXEYjL6HoDspZ6tDYVDvTUm",
      "shared_secret": "b4771fab61a8c51391c028376082c1e57e26bf4abd57c604280269c090d7036e",
      "commit": {
        "ver": 1,
        "repo": "did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz",
        "space": "at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general",
        "rev": "3mzudofhpw32e",
        "data": "e5a00aa9991ac8a5ee3109844d84a55583bd20572ad3ffcd42792f3c36b183ad"
      },
      "accept_signature": "m1=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeeRUs5P6aU9nQbNijvpHqdxXEYjL6HoDspZ6tDYVDvTUm\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";alg=\"hmac-sha256\"",
      "header": "ver=1, repo=\"did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz\", space=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general\", rev=\"3mzudofhpw32e\", data=:5aAKqZkayKXuMQmETYSlVYO9IFcq0//NQnkvPDaxg60=:",
      "base": "\"atproto-space-commit\";sf: ver=1, repo=\"did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz\", space=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general\", rev=\"3mzudofhpw32e\", data=:5aAKqZkayKXuMQmETYSlVYO9IFcq0//NQnkvPDaxg60=:\n\"@signature-params\": (\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeeRUs5P6aU9nQbNijvpHqdxXEYjL6HoDspZ6tDYVDvTUm\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";alg=\"hmac-sha256\"",
      "mac": "e1b1d8b3f35cb5e8a9ec37c61c05029981065b6bf12b951df6aacd13826f5b1c",
      "response": {
        "atproto-space-commit": "ver=1, repo=\"did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz\", space=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general\", rev=\"3mzudofhpw32e\", data=:5aAKqZkayKXuMQmETYSlVYO9IFcq0//NQnkvPDaxg60=:",
        "signature-input": "m1=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeeRUs5P6aU9nQbNijvpHqdxXEYjL6HoDspZ6tDYVDvTUm\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";alg=\"hmac-sha256\"",
        "signature": "m1=:4bHYs/Ncteip7DfGHAUCmYEGW2vxK5Ud9qrNE4JvWxw=:"
      }
    },
    {
      "comment": "a did:web repo and a 300-character skey",
      "author_private_key": "10258b259047e3e1f44beae062b93f53f9a889b7c47d5b95a840b56965b4254e",
      "key_share": "did:key:zDnaeSd7ficWutUFxyXdAANZx3aE8x3Y4vJEXjc9RGuhTTgSf",
      "shared_secret": "c62678cb5f148951245081d8cd8244231565db16bd10b96af192988ac3d2ba7d",
      "commit": {
        "ver": 1,
        "repo": "did:web:example.com",
        "space": "at://did:web:example.com/space/com.example.group/kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk",
        "rev": "3mzzzzzzzzz22",
        "data": "8ddb873663c61252967f811ca68af81e2e0431be5ad08d512f659cd071e90f48"
      },
      "accept_signature": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeSd7ficWutUFxyXdAANZx3aE8x3Y4vJEXjc9RGuhTTgSf\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "header": "ver=1, repo=\"did:web:example.com\", space=\"at://did:web:example.com/space/com.example.group/kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk\", rev=\"3mzzzzzzzzz22\", data=:jduHNmPGElKWf4Ecpor4Hi4EMb5a0I1RL2Wc0HHpD0g=:",
      "base": "\"atproto-space-commit\";sf: ver=1, repo=\"did:web:example.com\", space=\"at://did:web:example.com/space/com.example.group/kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk\", rev=\"3mzzzzzzzzz22\", data=:jduHNmPGElKWf4Ecpor4Hi4EMb5a0I1RL2Wc0HHpD0g=:\n\"@signature-params\": (\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeSd7ficWutUFxyXdAANZx3aE8x3Y4vJEXjc9RGuhTTgSf\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "mac": "15cbb814c31ec75901d6e5d1f70e4447db68775c172b6cee73374c452c1ee062",
      "response": {
        "atproto-space-commit": "ver=1, repo=\"did:web:example.com\", space=\"at://did:web:example.com/space/com.example.group/kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk\", rev=\"3mzzzzzzzzz22\", data=:jduHNmPGElKWf4Ecpor4Hi4EMb5a0I1RL2Wc0HHpD0g=:",
        "signature-input": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeSd7ficWutUFxyXdAANZx3aE8x3Y4vJEXjc9RGuhTTgSf\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
        "signature": "mac=:Fcu4FMMex1kB1uXR9w5ER9tod1wXK2zuczdMRSwe4GI=:"
      }
    }
  ],
  "record": [
    {
      "comment": "a record",
      "author_private_key": "10258b259047e3e1f44beae062b93f53f9a889b7c47d5b95a840b56965b4254e",
      "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
      "shared_secret": "afcf99a99e3e853a91662abc5201db0528e75737032b7dde252e9bf030735485",
      "uri": "at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general/did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz/com.example.note/3kabcdefghi22",
      "cid": "bafyreibqrvab2uuhh5j7dsrwjzptpmu3g42eiwvodyt67ojclmttqjjv4e",
      "accept_signature": "mac=(\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\"",
      "header": "uri=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general/did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz/com.example.note/3kabcdefghi22\", cid=\"bafyreibqrvab2uuhh5j7dsrwjzptpmu3g42eiwvodyt67ojclmttqjjv4e\"",
      "base": "\"atproto-space-record\";sf: uri=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general/did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz/com.example.note/3kabcdefghi22\", cid=\"bafyreibqrvab2uuhh5j7dsrwjzptpmu3g42eiwvodyt67ojclmttqjjv4e\"\n\"@signature-params\": (\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\"",
      "mac": "b5c8e452189671c3c7727e6d7c70dff00daac94ff22e28d291ccc9da7ff21f6e",
      "response": {
        "atproto-space-record": "uri=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general/did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz/com.example.note/3kabcdefghi22\", cid=\"bafyreibqrvab2uuhh5j7dsrwjzptpmu3g42eiwvodyt67ojclmttqjjv4e\"",
        "signature-input": "mac=(\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\"",
        "signature": "mac=:tcjkUhiWccPHcn5tfHDf8A2qyU/yLijSkczJ2n/yH24=:"
      }
    },
    {
      "comment": "a record keyed self",
      "author_private_key": "10258b259047e3e1f44beae062b93f53f9a889b7c47d5b95a840b56965b4254e",
      "key_share": "did:key:zDnaeeRUs5P6aU9nQbNijvpHqdxXEYjL6HoDspZ6tDYVDvTUm",
      "shared_secret": "b4771fab61a8c51391c028376082c1e57e26bf4abd57c604280269c090d7036e",
      "uri": "at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general/did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz/com.atproto.space.policy/self",
      "cid": "bafyreihycchfbqbhh6b72vxun2owtolp6vvyhjxhdjt36aw6teofhzrlyq",
      "accept_signature": "mac=(\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeeRUs5P6aU9nQbNijvpHqdxXEYjL6HoDspZ6tDYVDvTUm\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\"",
      "header": "uri=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general/did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz/com.atproto.space.policy/self\", cid=\"bafyreihycchfbqbhh6b72vxun2owtolp6vvyhjxhdjt36aw6teofhzrlyq\"",
      "base": "\"atproto-space-record\";sf: uri=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general/did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz/com.atproto.space.policy/self\", cid=\"bafyreihycchfbqbhh6b72vxun2owtolp6vvyhjxhdjt36aw6teofhzrlyq\"\n\"@signature-params\": (\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeeRUs5P6aU9nQbNijvpHqdxXEYjL6HoDspZ6tDYVDvTUm\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\"",
      "mac": "8e53b894ff3926e76bee22a1ea7c766d2224bf5e8ba8bbe3f0aeb1f2a5e7e705",
      "response": {
        "atproto-space-record": "uri=\"at://did:plc:3jpt2mvvsumj2r7eqk4gzzjz/space/com.example.forum/general/did:plc:ewvi7nxzyoun6zhxrhs64oiz/com.atproto.space.policy/self\", cid=\"bafyreihycchfbqbhh6b72vxun2owtolp6vvyhjxhdjt36aw6teofhzrlyq\"",
        "signature-input": "mac=(\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaeeRUs5P6aU9nQbNijvpHqdxXEYjL6HoDspZ6tDYVDvTUm\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\"",
        "signature": "mac=:jlO4lP85Judr7iKh6nx2bSIkv16LqLvj8K6x8qXn5wU=:"
      }
    }
  ],
  "accept_signature": [
    {
      "comment": "as the reference formats it",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "a record MAC asked for",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-record",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "another label",
      "header": "anything=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "anything",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "alg hmac-sha256",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";alg=\"hmac-sha256\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";alg=\"hmac-sha256\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "tag before keyid, kept in that order",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "sf written ?1, serialized as sf",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf=?1);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "keyid given twice: the last counts",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"x\";keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "spaces around the header",
      "header": "  mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"  ",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "another request tagged otherwise, passed over",
      "header": "x=(\"foo\");tag=\"other\", mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "a member that is no inner list, passed over",
      "header": "foo, mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "the label given twice: the last counts",
      "header": "mac=(\"x\");tag=\"x\", mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": {
        "label": "mac",
        "key_share": "did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU",
        "signature_params": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\""
      },
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "only a record MAC asked for, on a method answering a commit: no MAC",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-record\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "the tag a token, not a string: no MAC",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=atproto-space-commit",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "the tag in upper case: no MAC",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"ATPROTO-SPACE-COMMIT\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "the member no inner list: no MAC",
      "header": "mac=\"atproto-space-commit\";keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "empty: no MAC",
      "header": "",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": false
    },
    {
      "comment": "two requests tagged with the profile",
      "header": "a=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\", b=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "no sf",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\");keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "sf false",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf=?0);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "another parameter on the component",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf;bs);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "the component a token",
      "header": "mac=(atproto-space-commit;sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "another component beside it",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf \"@method\");keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "the record header covered, for a commit",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-record\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "no components",
      "header": "mac=();keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "alg another algorithm",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";alg=\"ecdsa-p256-sha256\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "alg a token",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";alg=hmac-sha256",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "created",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";created=1700000000",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "nonce",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\";nonce=\"x\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "no keyid",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "keyid a token",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=foo;tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "not a dictionary",
      "header": "(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf)",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "an upper-case parameter key, which no dictionary has",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);KEYID=\"did:key:zDnaezs81wvXFqkKzFv2nVGKB5FNTLvwnokhyyJgT7p7Zh2dU\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "a secp256k1 key share: refused when decapsulated",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:key:zQ3shbbLAkPZu2axswPJqzydKdtXc2eheioFsYCASnC1MC7eQ\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    },
    {
      "comment": "a key share that is no did:key: refused when decapsulated",
      "header": "mac=(\"atproto-space-commit\";sf);keyid=\"did:web:example.com\";tag=\"atproto-space-commit\"",
      "profile": "atproto-space-commit",
      "request": null,
      "refused": true
    }
  ]
}